VenSearch

California AI training data transparency law heads to federal appeals court November 18

VenSearch

VenSearch

· 1 min read

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has scheduled oral argument for November 18, 2026, in X.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591 — the first federal appellate test of a state law requiring generative AI developers to disclose information about their training data. The case centers on California Assembly Bill 2013, which has been in force since January 1, 2026, and requires any developer that makes a generative AI system available to Californians to publish a public summary covering 12 categories of training data, including data sources, types, intellectual property status, and whether personal information or synthetic data was used.
xAI, the company behind the Grok AI assistant, argues the law violates the First Amendment by compelling speech and the Fifth Amendment by forcing disclosure of trade secrets without compensation. California's position is that the disclosure requirement is a permissible transparency measure. A federal district court denied xAI's request to block the law in March 2026, and xAI appealed. Because the major national AI model developers all serve Californians, and because a single public posting satisfies the requirement regardless of where a user is located, the law effectively functions as a national baseline for training-data transparency.
Any organization that develops or substantially modifies generative AI tools — including internal enterprise models, customer-facing chatbots, or fine-tuned versions of third-party models — should be aware that the obligation is currently in force regardless of the appeal's outcome. The November 18 argument may affect how the law is ultimately enforced, but the Ninth Circuit's ruling is unlikely to arrive quickly. Organizations that procure AI tools from vendors may also want to confirm whether those vendors have published the required disclosures, since the duty falls on developers, not deployers.

Sources

  1. 1.Center for AI and Digital Policy ↗
  2. 2.Knight First Amendment Institute ↗
  3. 3.Corporate Compliance Insights ↗
  4. 4.SRP Lawyer ↗

Does this affect your business?

Our advisors can help you figure out the right move, at no cost.

Talk to an advisor